Thick Creamy Mayonnaise was one of the dressings they taught me in Culinary school. It’s so easy to make but there a few essential tips to know in order to make a thick mayo every time like the store-bought stuff. 

homemade mayonnaise whipped in a cup

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our full disclosure.

I use this homemade mayonnaise recipe in place of my favorite store-bought one (Hellman’s fan). In fact, I haven’t purchased mayonnaise in over a year now. It’s stable, long-lasting (thanks to the acidic ingredients), and my most go-to staple for making other creamy dressings at home. 

I’m trying to stay away from soybean oils so, finding a replacement was vital. Look no further for a Copycat Hellman’s Mayonnaise recipe! This mayo tastes like the real deal (read all the highly-rated five star reviews) and see for yourself. Even my sisters thought the taste was spot on, and they are avid Hellman’s users.  

We go through homemade dressings quickly! I use mayonnaise more than just a sandwich spread and often times more as the base for creamy dressings like Caesars dressing, Ranch Dressing, and Honey Mustard to name a few. 

Creamy Dressings especially mayonnaise have become a world wide staple! Asians make their version with rice wine vinegar and Ukrainian’s use it for their famous Potato salad (Olivye) and Beet Salad, we call Shuba. It’s so versatile and no little thing in our kitchen. 

 

perfectly whipped homemade mayonnaise

In Culinary school, we were taught that the components of a creamy base are usually mixed in the following ratio: 

  • 10% flavorings and aromatics
  • 60% creamy base (oil content to emulsify)
  • 30% acidic liquid

This ratio is a good guideline to start with but each creamy dressing must be tested and tasted for balance and texture according to the Chef. My recipe fits this ratio criteria being comprised of around 17% acidic component and lasts long. The acid works as the preservative in mayonnaise and can be substituted with whey, or the juice of Sauerkraut for a probiotic infused mayonnaise. 

Watch How To Make Mayonnaise:

Mise en Place for Making Mayonnaise: 

You will need a narrow jar or the container your Immersion blender comes with if using a stick blender. If making by hand use a bowl and a wire whisk. Have the measuring spoons, measuring cup, and storage container near by. 

mayonnaise ingredients

  • Acid- such as lemon juice and white distilled vinegar. 
  • Prepared Yellow Mustard- you could use dry mustard, Dijon mustard, or other prepared Mustards.
  • Neutral Flavored Oil- I use sunflower or avocado oil, it should be light and not overpowering. 
  • Seasonings- such as salt and sugar to enhance the flavor. 
  • Whole Egg and mustard helps the mayonnaise emulsify. 

Chef Pro Tip: Allow your eggs and acid to come to room temperature before making the dressing. If your mixture is too cold or hot during preparation the emulsion will become unstable. 

How To Make Mayonnaise:

thickened homemade mayonnaise

This process is for using an immersion blender! I include the instructions for using a food processor, Vitamix blender, or “by hand” technique in the recipe card below. 

  1. Place the whole egg and acid into a narrow container. A wide-mouth mason jar works well too.
  2. Top with the seasonings like salt and sugar (this is a good time to add coarse salt like Celtic salt).
  3. Pour oil over the top, DO NOT stir.  
  4. Plunge the stick blender into the bottom of the container and do not move up, keep it at the very bottom. Blend for 30-60 seconds or until the bottom half gets very stiff. Then slowly move your hand blender upwards in small second increments so, that the mixture emulsifies fully. A common mistake I see are up and down motions too soon, this will make a runny mayonnaise. Don’t rush the emulsification process. 

Assessing the Quality: 

Correctly made mayonnaise has a mild balanced and tangy flavor. It should be thick, creamy, and consistently smooth in texture and appearance. It’s white or slightly off-white in color and shouldn’t be greenish or too yellow. 

If your mayonnaise emulsion breaks it could be because you added the oil too quickly (if making by hand or other equipment where you’d slowly pour the oil in to emulsify). It could also be that the dressing became too warm or too cold during preparation.

To fix broken mayonnaise you can either place a whole egg in a clean new container and add the broken mayonnaise to emulsify again or you can combine an egg yolk and water and beat until foamy then add the broken mayonnaise, whisking constantly until it becomes smooth, creamy, and emulsified again. 

Mayonnaise Add-ins: 

At step four, after the components have been combined you can add in other flavorings and ingredients to create new dressings and sauces. For example; add spinach, watercress, parsley, and tarragon to create the green goddess dressing. This is a good time to add a mashed avocado or chipotle peppers for a spicy mayonnaise. 

how to make mayonnaise

Storing Homemade Mayonnaise

Homemade mayonnaise stores very well! Transfer the mayonnaise to a clean, airtight container like a wide-mouth mason jar. Refrigerate and use within 3-4 weeks (if using my recipe with an acidic component of around 17% or more). I often make a quart-full amount and like to scoop some into a squeeze bottle for quick sandwiches. Avoid leaving mayonnaise out in the open and exposed to air, as it will discolor, oxidize and taste rancid.

We were also taught in Culinary school that smooth homogenized mixtures like emulsified dressings last longer than a simple vinaigrette because of the amphipathic compounds which consist of both polar (from vinegar) and non-polar sections (from oil) blended to a smooth consistency. 

 

storing homemade mayonnaise in a squeeze bottle

Tips for Making Mayonnaise:

  1. Use an Immersion blender for foolproof mayonnaise. This is the technique I use and I have never had mayonnaise not turn out on me. I find that using a stick blender is easier to clean up too than washing  a bigger kitchen appliance. 
  2. Using raw eggs can be concern, in this case use pasteurized eggs. Buy grade AA eggs as they are the freshest eggs and best for making dressings as the yolks shouldn’t run. 
  3. If the mayonnaise is too stiff, add a splash of water, lemon juice or vinegar. 
  4. For gourmet mayonnaise add a drop of truffle oil to make truffle aioli, it’s amazing to dip with sweet potato fries!
  5. Are you out of prepared mustard? Use one teaspoon of ground mustard for one tablespoon of prepared mustard.
  6. Use apple cider vinegar for sweeter notes of flavor.
  7. Snip off the tip of your squeeze bottle for the creamy mayonnaise to flow out better.
  8. To make a thick emulsified mixture that has an effect on the taste, mouthfeel, and appearance make sure you use an egg and mustard to emulsify the mayonnaise properly. 
  9. If making a bigger batch, emulsify the mixture longer. 
  10. Refrigeration slows down the separation of acids and oils in emulsified creamy dressings. Always keep mayonnaise covered in an air-tight container to prevent oxidization.  

 

How To Make Mayonnaise

Prep Time: 5 minutes
Servings: 24 servings (yields 1.5 cups)
Thick Creamy Mayonnaise was one of the dressings they taught me in Culinary school. It's so easy to make but there a few essential tips to know in order to make a thick mayo every time like the store-bought stuff.  

Equipment

  • 1 immersion blender (and cup attachment)
  • 1 storage container (16 oz plastic squeeze bottle or wide-mouth mason jar)

Ingredients

Ingredients:

  • 1 whole egg
  • 1 Tbsp prepared yellow mustard
  • 1 tsp sea salt
  • 2 tsp lemon juice (juice from 1/2 small lemon)
  • 2 Tbsp white distilled vinegar
  • 11/4 cup sunflower oil (I like avocado oil or use any neutral flavored oil)

Instructions

Directions:

  • layer ingredients into an immersion blender cup to make mayo
    Place all the ingredients in the order given (egg, yellow mustard, lemon juice, vinegar, salt, sugar, and oil) into the cup that the immersion blender comes with, ending with the oil last. Do not stir.
  • emulsify the oil
    Plunge the stick blender onto the bottom of the cup. Turn the blender on and keep it on the bottom until the mixture starts to emulsify and becomes thick on the bottom half (about 30-60 seconds). *See notes for bigger batch.
  • Once the mayonnaise starts to thicken and emulsify slowly move the stick blender upward to continue to emulsify the ingredients. When it's almost combined I will then move my hand blender up and down to well combine any oil on the surface.
  • thickened homemade mayonnaise
    Mayonnaise should be thick and hard to blend at this stage, give it a final stir.
  • storing homemade mayonnaise in a squeeze bottle
    Transfer mayonnaise to an airtight container or squeeze bottle and keep in the fridge for up to 1 month.

Notes

Notes: 
  • You can use a wide-mouth mason jar to make mayonnaise, just layer the ingredients in there instead of the cup attachment to the blender. 
  • If you are making a bigger batch (such as a triple recipe) you will need to emulsify longer. I emulsify the mayonnaise for a good minute or so before even lifting the immersion blender to finish emulsifying. This makes a super thick mayonnaise. Moving the stick blender in up and down motion too soon will result in a runnier mayonnaise. 
  • If making mayonnaise by hand or in a food processor like the Vitamix blender you will need to mix the eggs with the acidic components first either by hand using a whisk or blending. Then add the oil in a thin stream whisking or beating vigorously to form an emulsion. It needs to be whipped into the egg to create a stable emulsion. Add the seasonings. 
  • To fix broken mayonnaise place a whole egg into a clean container or wide-mouth jar. You can add a splash of lemon juice or water and add the broken mayonnaise blending as instructed until it becomes smooth, creamy, and emulsified again. 
  • For Add ins: at step 4 you can add in other flavorings and ingredients to create new dressings and sauces. Simply blend in avocados, spinach, or chipotle peppers for different flavor profiles. 

Nutrition per serving

Serving: 1TablespoonCalories: 225kcalCarbohydrates: 0.2gProtein: 0.3gFat: 25gSaturated Fat: 3gPolyunsaturated Fat: 1gMonounsaturated Fat: 21gTrans Fat: 0.001gCholesterol: 7mgSodium: 106mgPotassium: 4mgFiber: 0.03gSugar: 0.2gVitamin A: 10IUVitamin C: 0.2mgCalcium: 2mgIron: 0.04mg

New Be featured here!

Hashtag #yesalyonascooking on both Instagram and Pinterest to be seen here!

Categories

5 from 4 votes

Leave a comment

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

14 comments

    • Valerie

    Can you use olive oil for this recipe?

      • Alyona Demyanchuk

      Hi Valerie, you could but the mayonnaise will have a strong olive oil taste.

    • Debi

    Love this recipe. My husband is a hellman mayo die hard
    I want to use the mustard seeds instead of the prepared mustard. Am I correct in understanding to use 1 tablespoons of water? Can I pulverize the mustard seeds? Thank you.

      • Alyona Demyanchuk

      Hi Debi, you can grind the mustard seeds, but I find that mustard powder is more concentrated than the prepared mustard from the bottle so you would need to adjust the amount of mustard seeds, otherwise your mayonnaise can be a bit bitter. I have not tried soaking the mustard seeds, so, do let us know how that works out.

    • Karen

    Beautiful, easy recipe. Love it

      • Alyona Demyanchuk

      Hi Karen, we love it too! We triple the recipe and always make it on repeat!

    • Maryane Dougherty

    How is this sooo good & so EASY?! Flawless recipe instructions & perfect results. Thank you so much for sharing.

      • Alyona Demyanchuk

      Your welcome Maryane! We’ve been making this mayonnaise eversince (I haven’t bought Hellmann’s since, it’s the perfect dupe)! Happy to hear your enjoying the recipe too!

        • Maryane

        Hello Alyona, I just made my 4th or 5th batch of your incredible (in taste & convenience) Mayo. I have been using Japanese vinegar because I ran out of my organic white vinegar & I urge you to try it!
        I plan to make jars of it to give at Christmas time to friends. It beats Hellman’s/Best Foods by a mile!
        It is also a way to reduce my plastic use (a mission I’m on to reduce plastic in my home) & recycle existing plastic jars. Thank you so much again & yes, I’ll be going through your site & exploring other treats. All the best, Maryane

          • Alyona Demyanchuk

          Hi Maryane, I really appreciate your comment. I’m so happy this has become a staple in your home. Which Japanese vinegar would you be referring to?

            • Maryane

            I use Nishiki Sushi vinegar. Maybe it’s the sweet? BTW, your Ranch dressing is also a staple in my home now. So many thanks, your creations are the best!

            • Alyona Demyanchuk

            Hi Maryanne, I’m so happy to hear your loving the recipes! I think rice or sushi vinegar would make a Japanese style Mayo called Kewpie, perfect for spicy mayonnaise, etc..

    • Daithi de Lyons

    I have used a lot of methods to make mayo and they have an unacceptable failure rate. If you make a big batch, losing 2 1/2 cups of expensive sunflower oil is too costly. Since we are allergic to soy this is a big problem seeing as we have to make our own.
    This method is awesome! I haven’t had any failures at all. I tried to make it fail testing using cold eggs and room temp oil with ingredients just out of fridge. No problem worked fine.
    The immersion blender paid for itself in just a few batches.

    Thank you!!!

      • Alyona Demyanchuk

      Hi, I’m so happy to hear this! Thanks for sharing!

Explore Recipes

See What Others Made!
#yesalyonascooking on pinterest or instagram to be featured

As Seen On

  • Mashed
  • Yummly
  • Parade
  • BuzzFeed
Alyona’s Cooking